To further investigate the shallow and deep processing, morris, bransford, and franks 1977 had participants encode words phonemically shallow processing or semantically deep processing. In contrast to the levels perspective, the transferappropriateprocessing position holds that encoded events are always represented in a semantic memory code morris et al. The way the learner processes the information when learning should match the way the learner processes the information for the test of learning. Levels of processing versus transfer appropriate processing 1977 journal of verbal learning and verbal behavior. Results showed that whereas there were agerelated differences in some tests. First, the processing done by subjects asked to generate only part of the target words at study would appear to overlap more with that needed for a cuedrecall test, whereas those asked to generate the complete target word would match.
Long term memory cognitive psychology flashcards quizlet. The science of learning was developed by member deans of deans for impact in close collaboration with dan willingham, a cognitive scientist at the university of virginia, and paul bruno, a former middleschool science teacher. Retrieval practice with shortanswer, multiplechoice, and. If so, one might expect retention to be greatest under. Learners who are low in comprehension skills might benefit more from instruction on generative activities, such as selfquestioning. When the retrieval task requires rhyme recognition, phonological processing gives. Mendenhall graduated from the university of utah with a b. The elaborative retrieval hypothesis is made up of two key assumptions. Both multiplechoice and shortanswer quizzes enhance later. Does the word rhyme with semantic study was better for standard recognition but not the phonological test.
Two experiments examined the effects of various semanticorienting tasks on immediate and delayed recall. Copyright 1996 by the american psychological association. Some investigations of comprehension and recall, journal of verbal learning and verbal behavior, 11. This allowed the assessment of accuracy and latency of retrievals. They said that it is possible that the better recall of meaningful material is due to the way the participants memories were tested. Create your citations, reference lists and bibliographies automatically using the apa, mla, chicago, or harvard referencing styles. Journal of verbal learning and verbal behavior 21, 165 174 1982 elaborative encoding as an explanation of levels of processing gary l.
Retrieval practice with shortanswer, multiplechoice, and hybrid tests megan a. Inspired in part by the theories and research of the august group of. Morris, bransford, and franks 1977 showed that semantic. Article information, pdf download for memory for sentences and prose. This eoffprint is provided exclusively for the personal use of the authors. Depth of processing and the retention of words in episodic memory pdf. In an experiment testing the idea of transferappropriate. Memory practical psychology bibliographies cite this for me. Memory for emotional and nonemotional events in depression. The effects of divided attention on encoding and retrieval. Transferappropriate processing, also referred to as tap, is a type of state dependent memory.
The effects of variable practice on the performance of. Morris, bransford and franks 1977levels of processing with rhyming recognition but with transfer appropriate processing, found. If this is the case, we expect that giving the participant a cue which is semantically related to the target, should enhance and help both the success of the search for the target as well as the ease in which this search is conducted. This was done to activate an expectation or intention in. The effects of variable practice on the performance. Morris bransford and franks 1977 levels of processing with recognition using a from psyc 1 at university of california, san diego. The effects of test trial and processing level on immediate. Transferappropriate processing, also referred to as tap, is a type of statedependent memory specifically showing that memory performance is not only determined by the depth of processing where associating meaning with information strengthens the memory. Karpicke department of psychological sciences, purdue university, west lafayette, in, usa received 29 may 20.
Information that is processed the same way at learning and at test e. The jenkins tetrahedral mode a model developed by james jenkins 1978 highlights important constellations of factors that must be simultaneously considered when attempting to think about issues of. Transferappropriate processing tap, as applied to implicit memory, has tended to emphasize general forms of processing e. Test format and corrective feedback modify the effect of. Stein, 1978 appears to be one of the principal ways to improve learning from multimedia information. An exciting and provocative application of cognitive psychology to education rests on basic findings showing that introducing difficulty into learning improves longterm performance and transfer. Cognitive psychology 2, 3350 1971 the abstraction of linguistic ideas1 john d.
Franks university of minnesota the phenomenon of idea acquisition and retention is demonstrated experimentally and contrasted with an. Franks vanderbilt university levels of processing were manipulated as a function of acquisition task and type of recognition test in three experiments. Tests enhance the transfer of learning university of south. Principles of effective retrieval final remarks about forgetting forgetting can occur at any. Many of these basic findings are related to the work of the researchers honored by this volume, as well as their colleagues work. On the use of the recall task to measure l2 reading. The generation effect when generation fails sciencedirect. Several recent studies have indicated that retrieval, unlike encoding, is only minimally affected by dividing attention, but is associated with significant secondary task costs. Within this framework, transferappropriate processing e. The effects of factoriented versus problemoriented. Experimental psychology your article has appeared in a journal published by hogrefe publishing. It is the engagement of similar operations on the intervening and final. Transferappropriate processing is a type of statedependent memory specifically showing that memory performance is not only determined by the depth of processing where associating meaning with information strengthens the memory.
Journal of verbal learning and verbal behavior 22, 153163 1983 the generation effect when generation fails norman j. The groups differed in socioeconomic status, verbal intelligence, and apparent levels of daily activity. Journal of verbal learning and verbal behavior 16, 519533 1977 levels of processing versus transfer appropriate processing c. Often cues that are effective following one type of encoding are shown to be ineffective following oth ers, while different cues formerly ineffective can be shown to be effective with the offprint request to h. Morris bransford and franks 1977 levels of processing with. By its very nature, an initial test bears more resemblance to a final test than does a restudy opportunity. Both multiplechoice and shortanswer quizzes enhance later exam performance in middle and high school classes kathleen b. Prospective memory 4 with repeated consecutive vowels will be focal because counting vowels will allow processing of the encoded feature of the pm cues. Erin mendenhall born 1980 is an american democratic politician who serves as the mayor of salt lake city, utah mendenhall was born in arizona and moved to sandy, utah when she was seven. Lists of words or word pairs were presented auditorily and recalled orally. Morris, bransford, and franks 1977 had subjects encode words either semantically or phonologically. At study, you will see a pair of words, one in lowercase the cue and one in uppercase the target. Applying psychological science to higher education. University of toronto in a generationeffect paradigm, generation of opposites to stimulus words was strongly influenced by the number of response letters provided.
In an experiment testing the idea of transferappropriate processing, morris, bransford, and franks 1977 had subjects encode words either semantically or phonologically. Morris, bransford and franks 1977 gave evidence against the levels of processing. In her report lisa hudson focuses on who is participating in postsecondary education. Daunting as it is to deliver something completely new, as a historian it is wonderful to get the opportunity to indulge in reading and research and. Anderson carnegiemellon university three experiments were performed to study how elaboration of memory structures affects recall accuracy and response latency. Mulligan and marilyn hartman university ofnorth carolina, chapelhill, north carolina attentional state during acquisition is an important determinant of performance on direct mem ory tests. Electrophysiological studies of retrieval processing michael d. Bransford and franks 1977 type of recall task determines whether deeper processing improves memory. Read, download and publish encoding magazines, ebooks for free at. This year i taught and designed new scheme for alevel history the british experience of warfare 1790 to 1918. Cognition chapter 5 remembering events fundamentals of. They found that semantic encoding led to greater recognition than phonemic encoding in standard recognition test. This was done to activate an expectation or intention in the participants for from ps 260 at wilfrid laurier university. Perhaps it is the similarity between initial and final tests, therefore, that drives the testing effect.
Transferappropriate processing, also referred to as tap, is a type of statedependent memory. Morris, bransford, and franks 1977 showed that semantic processing is better than phonological processing, but only when the retrieval task requires the remembrance of meaning. Levels of processing versus transfer appropriate processing. Assuming adequate consolidation whatever that is, an encoded memory, made rich and distinctive by elaborative and organizational processing, remains permanently in memory storage until needed, at which time it must be retrieved from storage, subject to interference, and put to use. In experiment 1, words modified by their core or crosssituational properties necessary adjectives were recalled better than words modified by more peripheral properties arbitrary adjectives. Employment of a multimeasure approach as a vehicle for.
The surprisingly powerful influence of drawing on memory. Pdf transferappropriate processing in recognition memory. Pdf transferappropriate processing in the testing effect. A parallel in the lexi cal memory domain to the levelsofprocessingeffect has been obtained in demonstrations that deeper processing the research reported here was supported by grant 634. The workshop on the knowledge economy and postsecondary education documents changes seen in the postsecondary education system. The colloquialism a picture is worth a thousand words has reverberated through the decades, yet there is very little basic cognitive research assessing the merit of. Elaborative encoding as an explanation of levels of processing. It is closely related to more recent processoriented interpretations of associations and dissociations between implicit and explicit memory e. Type of semantic elaboration and recall springerlink. Article pdf available in journal of experimental psychology learning. Levels of processing psychology bibliographies cite. Carol twigg surveys the ways that fouryear institutions are attempting to modify. The reported experiment manipulated the strength of preexperimental semantic associations, using a cuedrecall paradigm and a multimeasure approach. For example a text by morris bransford and franks 1977 found.
Curran, 1991, the similarity between encoding and re trieval is also challenged by findings fram the paradigm. Which of these words rhymes with one youve seen before. Tom bailey concentrates on community colleges as the most responsive institutions to employer needs. Involving the stimulus by maggie jinghua xiong dissertation submitted to the faculty of the graduate school of vanderbilt university in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of doctor of philosophy in psychology may, 2005 approved. The present research focuses on the semantic priming phenomenon in word recognition. This bibliography was generated on cite this for me on monday, january 18, 2016. Superiority of free recall to cued recall with strong cu es. Abstractlockhart and craik l990 interpreted the results of morris, bransford, and franks 1977 as showing a main effect of level of encoding. Morris, bransford, and franks 1977 argued that semantic deeper processing is better than phonological shallow only when the retrieval task requires the remembrance of meaning i. When the retrieval task requires rhyme recognition, phonological processing gives superior results. These are the sources and citations used to research multi sore memory, levels of processing and eyewitness testimony.
Three groups of people ranging in age from 64 to 88 years performed tasks of word generation, pairedassociate recall, also free and cued recall. Asked ss to perform a physical recall task after they performed a physical encoding task. Sep, 2007 bransford and franks 1977 type of recall task determines whether deeper processing improves memory. The use of technology inandoutside second language. The critical, common factor appears to be transferappropriate processing.
A fourth group, consisting of young undergraduates, was also tested. Electrophysiological studies of retrieval processing. Further consideration of the data, however, reveals that this supposed main effect of study was confounded. Applied to the current context, this framework provides an alternative explanation for the testing effect. In other words, this account attributes the testing effect to the similarity between the learning strategy initial test. Theoretically speaking, synchronous forms of computermediated instruction such as online text chatting should then be conducive to automatizing learners l2 production skills in spontaneous. The authors examined the effects of divided attention da at encoding and retrieval in free recall, cued recall, and recognition memory in 4 experiments. Therefore, it is possible that the transfer from free recall to recognition is also. The present experiment evaluated these ideas by varying both the strategies em ployed by bilingual subjects during en. In two experiments we investigated the effects of dividing attention during acquisition on.
70 1468 1119 1463 109 272 623 552 1319 200 311 903 1332 264 1131 872 288 161 785 707 645 924 247 1101 866 428 1517 1209 1046 514 1477 28 1162 383 1110 298 949 150 1267 825 432